Citizens Property Insurance, Explained: Florida’s Insurer of Last Resort

If you’ve been dropped by a Florida homeowners insurer — or quoted a price that made you laugh out loud — someone has probably said to you: “Try Citizens.”

Citizens Property Insurance is real, it’s run by the State of Florida, and it might be your answer. But it doesn’t work like a normal insurance company, and walking in with the wrong expectations wastes time. Here’s how it actually works.

What Citizens is

Citizens is a not-for-profit insurer the State of Florida created for homeowners who can’t get coverage in the regular market. It’s called the insurer of last resort for a reason: it’s meant to be the backup, not the first call. Citizens itself will tell you it doesn’t try to compete with private companies.

You can’t just choose it — you have to qualify

This is the part that surprises people. To get a Citizens policy, you generally have to show one of two things:

  • No private insurer will offer you comparable coverage, or
  • The private coverage you can get costs more than 20% above what Citizens would charge for comparable coverage

If a private company offers you a policy within that 20% range, you’re expected to take the private policy. Applications are checked against private-market offers through a state clearinghouse — so this isn’t paperwork you can skip.

The same test comes back at renewal

Already with Citizens? The test repeats. Private insurers regularly offer to take over Citizens policies (it’s called depopulation). If a private offer lands within 20% of your Citizens renewal premium, you generally can’t stay with Citizens — even if you’d rather. If the offer is more than 20% above, you can choose to stay, but you have to actively respond and say so. Silence can mean your policy moves.

A few more things worth knowing

  • Rates are capped, but they still rise. State law limits how fast Citizens can raise rates — the cap for primary homes is 15% a year under current law — but capped is not frozen.
  • Flood is separate, and increasingly required. Citizens has been phasing in a flood-insurance requirement for its wind policyholders. Ask about it before you bind, so it isn’t a surprise later.
  • Assessments are possible. If a catastrophic storm season overwhelms Citizens’ reserves, Florida law allows surcharges — Citizens policyholders first, and in extreme cases other Florida policyholders too. It’s rare, but it’s part of the deal with a state backstop.

The bottom line

Citizens is a safety net, and a real one — plenty of good Florida homes are insured there right now. Just go in clear-eyed: you have to qualify, the private market gets checked first, and it can hand you back to a private insurer later. For many dropped homeowners, that’s still far better than the alternative — no coverage at all.

Dropped, priced out, or trying to figure out whether Citizens or a private policy is your better path? Our Homeowners Insurance page explains how we connect Florida homeowners with licensed partners who write here: Compare your homeowners options — or call us at 954-249-2189.

Related reading: Your Florida Insurer Dropped You? Here’s the Step-by-Step Plan and The Wind Mitigation Inspection That Can Lower Your Premium